Best Pizza in Bluffton, SC: Top Local Spots for a Slice You’ll Love
Bluffton has a way of blending its laid-back Lowcountry charm with big, satisfying flavors, and pizza is no exception. Around town, you’ll find spots that treat pizza like an art form, crafting dough from scratch and layering on toppings with care, as well as neighborhood favorites that keep things simple and comforting. It’s a mix that reflects Bluffton itself — welcoming, creative, and always rooted in community.
Whether you’re craving a classic hand-tossed pie, a wood-fired specialty with gourmet flair, or just a dependable slice to enjoy with friends, Bluffton’s pizza scene delivers. Here are the Best Pizza Restaurants in Bluffton, SC — each offering its own spin on a dish that’s as versatile as it is beloved.
Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta
A local favorite serving award-winning pies
Giuseppi’s has been part of the Bluffton dining scene for decades, and it’s the kind of place that locals rely on when they’re craving classic, hand-tossed pizza. Their dough is made fresh daily, topped with quality ingredients, and baked to perfection in stone deck ovens. From traditional cheese and pepperoni to specialty pies loaded with creative toppings, Giuseppi’s delivers the kind of pizza that feels both familiar and satisfying.
What makes Giuseppi’s stand out is the balance between tradition and variety. While pizza is the star of the show, the menu also includes pastas, sandwiches, wings, and salads — making it a great choice for groups with mixed cravings. But it’s their consistent, crowd-pleasing pizzas that keep Bluffton families coming back week after week.
Why We Picked Them: Because Giuseppi’s represents Bluffton’s classic pizza experience, with fresh dough, quality ingredients, and a reputation built over years of serving the community.
Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta – Bluffton
25 Bluffton Road, Suite 601
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-815-9200
giuseppispizza.com
Frankie Bones
Italian-American dining with standout flatbreads
Frankie Bones is one of Bluffton’s favorite spots for steaks, pasta, and classic Italian-American comfort food. But tucked into their menu is a lineup of flatbreads that feel right at home in a pizza roundup. Crispy, thin crusts topped with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection make them a great alternative when you’re craving pizza in a more polished setting.
The flatbreads range from simple cheese and pepperoni combinations to creative toppings that match the rest of their menu’s flair. Served in a retro-inspired dining room with a little more style than the average pizza shop, these flatbreads give you the best of both worlds — the flavors you love in a setting that feels like an occasion.
Why We Picked Them: Because Frankie Bones proves you don’t have to be a pizza joint to serve a pie that delivers comfort and flavor.
Frankie Bones Bluffton
26 Discovery Drive
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-757-3423
frankiebones.com
Dough Boys Pizza
Family-owned, scratch-made pies that locals swear by
If you’re after pizza that hits every mark — fresh dough, inventive toppings, and a menu built around what a true pizza fan wants — look no further than Dough Boys Pizza in Bluffton. Their menu shows they’re serious about the craft: everything from “Build Your Own” pies with hand-tossed or thin crusts, to specialty creations like the “Big Caruna” (half sausage, half pepperoni, red pepper flakes, ricotta) and “Mike’s Cheeseburger Pizza” (special sauce base, ground beef, bacon, sweet onion, tomato, pickle).
What really sets Dough Boys apart is how they combine quality and variety. Their dough is made in-house with organic spring wheat flour, the sauce uses San Marzano tomatoes, and they offer gluten-free crust options so more folks can enjoy the experience. Add to that a full bar, comfortable dining room, and a location that’s both casual and polished — you’ve got a solid go-to for pizza in Bluffton.
Why We Picked Them: Because Dough Boys Pizza shows you can treat a pizza night like something special — without losing the “come as you are” comfort of a local favorite.
Dough Boys Pizza
1230 May River Rd Suite D
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-757-2697
doughboysbluffton.com
Mellow Mushroom
Creative stone-baked pizzas in a vibrant setting
Mellow Mushroom in Bluffton delivers handcrafted pizzas baked in stone ovens, with premium ingredients and inventive flavor combinations. Their menu shows they’re serious about pizza — whether you go classic or choose something more adventurous, the crust, toppings, and seasoning all come together perfectly.
What makes this spot stand out is the full experience: a lively atmosphere, a strong draft-beer selection, and a place where pizza night feels a little more elevated without losing its fun.
Why We Picked Them: Because Mellow Mushroom shows that Bluffton pizza options go beyond the expected — delivering quality, creativity, and atmosphere in one.
Mellow Mushroom – Bluffton
878 Fording Island Road
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-706-0800
mellowmushroom.com
Bluffton Pizza Company
Neighborhood-pie joint with build-your-own freedom
Bluffton Pizza Company focuses squarely on pizza pies: build-your-own options, specialty signature pies, and all the crust and topping flexibility you’d hope for. Their menu emphasizes scratch-made crusts, fresh ingredients, and a mix of classic and creative flavors.
Locals love this place for its dependable delivery and the ability to customize your pizza just how you like it. The wings and chopped salads are strong sides if your group wants variety.
Why We Picked Them: Because Bluffton Pizza Company delivers what any pizza lover seeks in a town: strong focus, good taste, and a sense of place.
Bluffton Pizza Company
4376 Bluffton Parkway, Unit 202
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-836-1030
blufftonpizzacompany.com
Local Pie
Family-owned, scratch-made pies that locals swear by
If you’re after pizza that hits every mark — fresh dough, inventive toppings, and a menu built around what a true pizza fan wants — look no further than Local Pie. Their menu shows they’re serious about the craft: everything from “Build Your Own” pies with hand-tossed or thin crusts, to specialty creations like the “Little Bear” with sausage, pepperoni, and sliced meatballs, or the “Suped Up” piled high with classic toppings. They even offer a Sicilian thick-crust option for those who like their pies hearty.
What really sets Local Pie apart is how they combine quality and variety. Their dough is made in-house with organic flour, their sauce uses San Marzano tomatoes, and they offer a gluten-free crust so everyone can enjoy. Add in a full bar and a comfortable, welcoming dining room, and you’ve got a go-to pizza spot in Bluffton that feels both special and down-to-earth.
Why We Picked Them: Because Local Pie shows you can treat pizza night like something worth savoring — without losing the laid-back comfort of a neighborhood favorite.
Local Pie
15 State of Mind Street
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-837-7437
localpie.com
The Upper Crust
Hand-tossed pizza in a relaxed neighborhood setting
The Upper Crust offers a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere paired with a solid pizza menu — hand-tossed dough, premium sauces, and a variety of fresh toppings set the stage for a comfortable, reliable pizza night.
What stands out about The Upper Crust is its blend of traditional and casual. You’ll find beloved classics like pepperoni and cheese alongside more creative flavor combinations, all served in a spot that doesn’t try too hard — it simply delivers what you want: good pizza in a place that feels like home.
Why We Picked Them: Because The Upper Crust serves up pizza with consistency and comfort, making it a dependable go-to in Bluffton’s pizza lineup.
The Upper Crust – Bluffton
30 William Pope Drive, Suite 105
Bluffton, SC 29909
843-705-5520
uppercrustbluffton.com
New York City Pizza
Authentic New York flavor with a Southern welcome
New York City Pizza brings a true taste of the Big Apple to Bluffton, serving hand-tossed pies made with fresh dough, quality mozzarella, and classic tomato sauce. Their New York–style pizzas feature thin, foldable slices with that perfect balance of crisp and chew, just like the city’s originals. The menu also includes pasta dishes, subs, and Italian favorites, making it a reliable go-to for both quick slices and family dinners.
What makes New York City Pizza stand out is its consistency — every pizza comes out flavorful and perfectly baked, whether you’re dining in or taking out. The relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere makes it a comfortable spot for locals and visitors alike.
Why I Picked Them: Because New York City Pizza delivers the kind of authentic, no-nonsense pizza that keeps people coming back for more — simple, delicious, and exactly what you expect from the name.
New York City Pizza – Bluffton
103 Buckwalter Place Blvd, Unit 108
Bluffton, SC 29910
(843) 837-4800
newyorkcitypizza.com
La Pizzeria
Authentic Italian pizza with family tradition
La Pizzeria is one of Bluffton’s hidden gems for those who appreciate a true Italian-style pie. Family-owned and operated, this spot focuses on quality over flash — serving handmade pizzas with perfectly crisp crusts, rich sauces, and fresh mozzarella that bring out the best of classic Italian simplicity. Their menu extends beyond pizza, with calzones, subs, and hearty pasta dishes that make every visit feel like a home-cooked meal.
What makes La Pizzeria stand out is its commitment to authenticity. Each pizza is prepared with care, baked to golden perfection, and served in a laid-back, welcoming space that feels more like a neighborhood kitchen than a restaurant. It’s a go-to for those who want great food without pretense — just solid, satisfying Italian comfort done right.
Why I Picked Them: Because La Pizzeria proves that great pizza doesn’t need gimmicks — just fresh ingredients, time-honored recipes, and a little love from the oven.
La Pizzeria – Bluffton
1460 Fording Island Road, Suite 230
Bluffton, SC 29910
843-757-4444
lapizzeriahhi.com
A Slice of Bluffton
Pizza in Bluffton is more than just a meal — it’s a reflection of the town’s personality. Some spots keep things classic with hand-tossed pies and family recipes, while others push the envelope with gourmet toppings or creative flatbreads. No matter where you go, the common thread is quality, comfort, and the kind of hospitality that makes Bluffton such a special place to eat.
From long-time neighborhood favorites to fresh takes on an old tradition, Bluffton’s pizza scene offers something for everyone. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after a day on the water or sitting down for a night out with friends, you’ll find that every pie tells its own story — one rooted in flavor, community, and a love for sharing good food.
Gary Elliott, together with his wife Shelley, chose a career in real estate in the Hilton Head area to share their passion for the Lowcountry lifestyle with others. With certifications as Bluffton and Hilton Head Ambassadors, Certified Military on the Move Specialists, Certified Relocation Specialists, and Certified Pricing Strategy Advisors, Gary and Shelley are well-equipped to assist clients in finding the ideal property.
